Title

Constitutive Arguments

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2010

Publication Title

Philosophy Compass

Department

Philosophy

Abstract

Can the question “Why do what morality requires?” be answered in such a way that anyone regardless of their desires or interests has reason to be moral? One strategy for answering this question appeals to constitutive arguments. In general, constitutive arguments attempt to establish the normativity of rational requirements by pointing out that we are already committed to them insofar as we are believers or agents. This study is concerned with the general prospects for such arguments. It starts by explaining the general constitutive argument strategy, followed by an examination of constitutive arguments that have been given regarding theoretical reason and the instrumental principle in practical reason, and concluding with a discussion of some challenges to constitutive arguments in moral philosophy and some possible responses to these challenges.

Volume

5

Issue

8

pp.

656-666

ISSN

1747-9991

Link to Full Text

Share

COinS