Did Milton Friedman's Methodology License the Formalist Revolution?
Journal of Economic Methodology
This paper examines two conflicting views that have emerged within the recent methodological literature regarding the relationship between Friedman's famous essay and the formalist revolution. I focus on three influential contributors to this ongoing debate: Mark Blaug, Terence Hutchison, and Thomas Mayer. Blaug and Hutchison have argued repeatedly that Friedman's essay licensed the formalist revolution while Mayer has argued precisely the opposite; the formalist revolution was a result of not following Friedman's methodological advice. The juxtaposition of these views is particularly interesting since the authors disagree sharply about the impact of Friedman's essay, and yet seem to agree about most other aspects of economic methodology.
"Did Milton Friedman's Methodology License the Formalist Revolution?" Journal of Economic Methodology, 10, 2003, 507-20 [reprinted in The International Library of Critical Writing in Economics: Recent Developments in Methodology, Vol. III, John B. Davis (ed.), Edward Elgar, 2006, 425-438]